Church Property Restitution – the Dark Shadow Obscuring the “Bright Future” of U.S.-Romanian Bilateral Relations

On June 9, 2017, at their joint White House press conference, President Trump applauded Romanian President Klaus Iohannis for his “courageous efforts in Romania to fight corruption and defend the rule of law,” speaking of the “bright future” between the two nations. Nothing could be further from the truth, however, for Romania’s 1.5 million ethnic Hungarian minority and the country’s Greek Catholic and Jewish religious minorities who, since the fall of communism, continue to be denied full religious, minority and property rights. 

  • Clearly, the Romanian President was not called to account for the scandalous 29-year failure of each successive government to restore more than but a fraction of the 13,379 church properties illegally confiscated by the State from their rightful owners between 1945 and 1989. 
  • Apparently, President Trump was not appraised that the Omnibus Appropriations Act of 2016 instructed the Department of State to report, within 90 days of enactment, on steps taken by the Government of Romania and the State Department to restore confiscated church properties to their legal owners, and that the ensuing report contained false information propagated by the Romanian authorities. 
  • Nor did President Iohannis have to explain the definition of rule of law in which a corrupt judiciary can collude with the state anti-corruption prosecutor (DNA) in persecuting civil servants for carrying out their official duties, re-nationalize a Protestant high school already legally restored to its rightful owner, and take orders from the government not to adjudicate the 18-year running Batthyaneum Library case. These issues were reported in the Department of State’s International Religious Freedom Report for 2016 and 2017  

The harsh reality is that the State Department is aware of the gravity of the situation, but at the same time, out of solutions to resolve the increasingly multi-faceted and entrenched human rights violations suffered by these religious denominations. As the year of the socially divisive centennial of Romania’s national holiday (the 1918 declaration by Romanians to unify Transylvania with Romania) draws to an end, anti-Hungarian sentiment is on the rise. 

Thus, renewed efforts are needed to achieve justice for these beleaguered religious minorities, with particular focus on the violations summarized below.  

The Numbers That Speak for Themselves

  • According to the Romanian Government’s own restitution body (referred to as NAPR, National Authority for Property Restitution, by the State Department) 14,814 is the total number of properties illegally confiscated from religious denominations by the Romanian communist regime in the 1945-1989 period.  
  • 2,140 of these buildings (housing schools, hospitals, orphanages and other social institutions) alone were taken from the four historic Hungarian churches – Roman Catholic, Hungarian Reformed (Protestant), Lutheran and Unitarian. 
  • 29 years after the 1989 Romanian Revolution and the overthrow of communism, 66.13 percent of these Hungarian minority properties is still not fully restituted by the Romanian state.  

The International Religious Freedom Reports for both 2016 and 2017 released by the U.S. State Department confirm a complete shutdown of any forward movement to return properties to their rightful owners. In 2016, the Report states “The government rejected more than 1,000 restitution claims for previously confiscated religious properties and approved 28;” while “as of December [2017] the government rejected 980 restitution claims for confiscated religious properties and approved 26.” These numbers are for all the affected religious denominations – the four Hungarian historic churches, Greek Catholic and Jewish. 

Our first-hand sources in Romania confirm that this preposterous situation remains unchanged in 2018. 

How is this possible? 

While the National Authority for Property Restitution should be accelerating the pace at which it approves claims,
it has placed additional roadblocks in the process for the past three years. 

The State Department International Religious Freedom Report for 2017 notes that “the Reformed, Roman Catholic, Unitarian, and Evangelical Lutheran churches said the government continued [emphasis added] to reject their restitution claims on the grounds the entities registered as the former property owners were not the contemporary churches. Church leaders said the communist regime had dismantled the former church entities while confiscating their property, meaning the former property owners no longer existed as such but the contemporary churches, as the successors to the dismantled churches, were in effect the same entities whose property had been seized” (page 13).  

This latest ploy began in 2012, but since at least May 2016 the Romanian authorities have been falsely insisting that this is not the case. Specifically, during the preparation of the report mandated by the afore-mentioned Omnibus Act, the Romanian authorities insisted to the U.S. Embassy in Bucharest that Parliament had adopted a law5 that eliminated all impediments to returning all the outstanding properties not yet restored to the four Hungarian historic churches and, as a result of the new law, those hundreds of claims filed Churches where title was jointly shared with auxiliary church institutions would no longer be rejected. 

In fact, the new law did nothing of the sort and had nothing whatsoever to do with the genuine impediments faced by religious denominations. Already in a June 2016 visit to Washington D.C., Bishop Béla Kató of the Hungarian Reformed Church, and subsequently the Democratic Alliance of Hungarians in Romania (representing the Hungarian minority politically), as well as HHRF staff on the ground in Romania, all confirmed that information received and reported by the State Department from official Romanian sources was false. 

So, what does this new law (No. 103/2016) actually do? 

  1. Paves the way for those claimants who were forced to “donate” their properties during World War II and the communist era to now file claims.  
  2. Establishes continuity of ownership of communal property by recognizing certain present-day inheritors of same as legitimate.  
  3. Accords priority to private claims by Holocaust survivors.   

None of these provisions remove the roadblocks used to deny the four historic Hungarian Churches’ rightful claims. Most importantly, what is missing entirely from the new law is a provision to unequivocally stipulate that properties confiscated by the former communist regime must be returned to the legal successors.  

Based on these facts, the only logical conclusion is that the Romanian authorities were deliberate in their attempt to mislead U.S. officials. Meantime, the Special Restitution Committee continues to reject hundreds of claims by the Hungarian churches under the pretext that the claimant and the original owner are not the same legal entity or its true successor.  In the last three months, the Roman Catholic Church was denied restitution and possession of three schools: the high school in Gyulafehervár/Alba Iulia, the Marianum in Kolozsvár/Cluj-Napoca and the Szacsvay Imre Elementary School in Nagyvárad/Oradea. 

The Romanian State persecutes those civil servants on the Special Restitution Committee
who faithfully carry out their duties, according to law 

Ethnic Hungarian former Member of Parliament, high-ranking Romanian government official, and member of the Special Restitution Committee Attila Markó’s tribulation began in 2010 when he was falsely charged with “official abuse of power” for deciding to return the Székely Mikó Protestant High School in Sepsiszentgyörgy/Sfântu Gheorghe to its rightful owner, the Hungarian Reformed Church. The building had been confiscated from the church in 1948 and the decision to return it was straight-forward. Nevertheless, Romanian prosecutors fabricated an indictment, and in June 2012, the court sentenced three members of the restitution committee involved in the decision — Attila Markó, Tamás Marosán and Silviu Clim — to three years of imprisonment. The witch-hunt did not stop there: later on, Mr. Markó was forced to resign from the Romanian Parliament, his reputation ruined and even further besmirched by false allegations of impropriety in other property-related cases where he wasn’t even involved. 

Why does the Romanian Anti-Corruption Agency (DNA) want to 
destroy Mr. Markó’s reputation at all costs and put him behind bars? 

The answer is unsettling: he had to be silenced because he fulfilled his duties on the Special Restitution Committee too effectively; too many properties were returned to the historic Hungarian Churches during his tenure. 

This assertion is underpinned by official statistics from the National Authority for Property Restitution: In the six years since the above-mentioned three civil servants were sentenced in 2012, the Committee has rejected 87.2 percent of all claims submitted by religious denominations (including Greek Catholic and Jewish): 

Total number of claims: 3,381 
Rejected by Committee 2,936
Compensation Provided  108
Restitution Granted   71 
Withdrawn by Claimants 233

The reason behind the large percentage of negative decisions is self-evident: Fear. Current members of the Special Restitution Committee do not want to risk unjust prosecution and possible imprisonment for doing their job (well) as did Markó, Marosán and Clim In fact, for years the government could not fill the seven positions on the Committee. Rather, they deny most claims submitted by the four historic Hungarian Churches for the return of their schools, kindergartens, orphanages, and so on. 

The undeniable reality is that the Romanian authorities are taking advantage of a legitimate and warranted anti-corruption struggle and achieving their obvious goal: to return as few properties as possible to the four historic Hungarians Churches, Greek Catholic and Jewish denominations. 

The Romanian State simply re-nationalizes high-profile and
valuable religious properties to assert their power over minorities
and set legal precedents 

On November 22, 2018 the Romanian Supreme Court ruled for the state and the renationalization of the Hungarian Protestant High School in the town of Sfântu Gheorghe/Sepsiszentgyörgy, leaving the European Court of Human Rights as the only recourse for justice. For the fourth time in 70 years, this property has been stolen from its rightful owner, setting a dangerous legal precedent in the country: 

First nationalized in 1948. The Special Restitution Committee restored the property in 2000 to the Church. 2012, nationalized a second time. Twelve years later, the State begins criminal proceedings, the courts take the school way from the Church, and sentences the 3 members of the National Authority for Property Restitution for the original 2000 decision. In 2014, the appellate court upholds the decision of the lower court. 2016, nationalized for the third time. The Church again submits a claim to the Special Restitution Committee in April 2016, which denies it in June. The last domestic recourse, the Supreme Court of Romania, denies the Church’s appeal two years later, on November 22, 2018, nationalizing the Székely Mikó High School for the fourth time in 70 years.  

In an interview given to the Hungarian Press Agency (MTI) Bishop Béla Kató expressed his indignation about the ruling, which brands the victim a “crook and thief” when in fact it is the state appropriating what it has no claim to.  

Overt judicial interference by the Romanian government to keep
properties for the State deemed too valuable (monetarily or
prestige) to relinquish 

Since 1998, the Romanian authorities have done everything in their power not to give back the renowned Batthyaneum Library and Astronomical Observatory to the Roman Catholic Church. True, the institution is of inestimable cultural, historic and bibliophile value (the Codex Aureus it houses is alone reportedly worth 10 Billion USD), but its rightful owner is the Archdiocese of Alba Iulia/Gyulafehérvár. 

Even though on September 25, 2012 the European Court of Human Rights fined and ordered the Romanian State to hand over the property (ECHR 33003/03), ever since the Church has been forced to file numerous lawsuits and appeals to the Special Restitution Committee to seek compliance. In April 2016, at the behest of the Romanian government, the Alba Iulia Court of Appeals indefinitely postponed a ruling in the case. Then, more than two years later on July 4, 2018, the Court rejected restituting the library to its rightful owner. The Roman Catholic Church has had to file yet another appeal, now to the Bucharest Supreme Court. 

Similar to other high-profile, valuable properties rightfully belonging to the Hungarian historic Churches, the authorities (whether the government and its affiliated agencies, or the judiciary) continue to delay, deny and simply cherry-pick those aspects of the law and the restitution process that serve its interests, thereby preventing return of the Batthyaneum to the rightful owner.  

Major Legal Milestones in the Roman Catholic Church’s Efforts  to Regain the Batthyaneum Library 

  • 1998.  Emergency Government Ordinance (EGO) No. 3/1998 orders that the Batthyaneum Library and Astronomical Observatory be returned to the Roman Catholic Church. 

  • Restitution never happens. On September 29, 1998, the local branch of the then ruling Social Democrat Party (PSD) brings a lawsuit against the Roman Catholic Archdiocese, the Romanian Academy and the Government of Romania.  

  • 2002. After a legal dispute lasting five and a half years, on March 7, 2002, the court recognizes the Archdiocese's right of ownership over the library and the observatory. In response, the Romanian authorities refuse for the second time to hand over the property
  • 2012. Ten years later, the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) in Strasbourg decides on the Church’s appeal.  On September 25, 2012, the Court rules (ECHR 33003/03) in favor of the plaintiff, stating that Romania has violated Protocol No. 1 of the European Convention on Human Rights by delaying the restitution of the building for 14 years. Furthermore, it rules that the Romanian State pay 25,000 euros compensation for non-material damage.  
  • 2015. The government pays the fine but does not return the property. The Archdiocese repeatedly petitions the Special Restitution Committee to abide by the ECHR decision and approve legal title and possession of the Batthyaneum Library. Three years later, the Committee rejects the Archdiocese’s request (in a vote of 6 nays, 1 abstention), on September 16, 2015.  
  • On November 12, 2015, the Archdiocese yet again files a lawsuit against the Special Restitution Committee’s decision. 
  • 2016. At the behest of the Romanian Government, on April 26, 2016, the Alba Iulia Court of Appeals announces an indefinite postponement of the case
  •  2018. On July 4, 2018 after 23 postponements in the case, the Alba Iulia Court of Appeals rejects restitution of the library to its rightful owner. The Roman Catholic Church now has to appeal to the Bucharest Supreme Court. 

Conclusion  

Demonstrably, the assault against the Hungarian minority, its religious institutions, and other minority religious denominations is being orchestrated at the highest levels of the Romanian government, and that is where it has to be stopped. 

As the major force behind pressing the Romanian government to adopt anti-corruption measures, the United States has the credibility to tell the Romanian government it has over-reached and its actions must be reversed to serve the intended original purposes. 

 

 

Hungarian Human Rights Foundation 
Magyar Emberi Jogok Alapítvány 

United States: 120 East 90th Street, Suite 5D, New York, NY 10128; tel: 1-212-289-5488; fax: 1-212-996-6268; e-mail: hamos[at]hhrf[dot]org 
Magyarország: 1255 Budapest, pf. 66.; tel: +36-1-795-5940, 5941; fax: +36-1-795-0458; e-mail: zsigmond[at]hhrf[dot]org 
Romania: str. Moţilor 9., 400001 Cluj; tel: +40-735-445003; e-mail: mazs[at]hhrf[dot]org 
http://www.hhrf.org

2018. dec. 06.
Kijevben összeállított feketelista alapján határátlépéskor rendszeresen zaklatják a kárpátaljai magyar önkormányzati képviselőket, újságírókat és aktivistákat az Ukrán Biztonsági Szolgálat (SZBU) és a határőrség munkatársai - írta 2018. december 6-...
Címkék:
2018. dec. 05.
Megtisztelőnek nevezte az ENSZ kisebbségügyi különmegbízottja, Fernand de Varennes, hogy 2018. december 5-én Kolozsváron, a Vallásszabadság házában fogadták a történelmi magyar egyházak vezetői, akik az egyházi ingatlanok visszaszolgáltatása körüli...
2018. nov. 22.
A legfelsőbb bíróság 2018. november 22-én jogerősen elutasította a sepsiszentgyörgyi Székely Mikó Kollégium államosított épületeinek a visszaszolgáltatását. A bírói testület háromszori halasztás után hozott döntést a restitúció elutasításáról. Az...
2018. nov. 22.
A fasizmus legyőzésére szólító ukrán nyelvű magyarellenes óriásplakátokat helyeztek el ismeretlenek több helyütt csütörtökön Kárpátalján - adta hírül a mukachevo.net munkácsi hírportál. Az óriásplakátokon Hennagyij Moszkal, Kárpátalja megye...
2018. nov. 08.
A román legfelsőbb bíróság ismét elhalasztotta a jogerős ítélet kihirdetését a sepsiszentgyörgyi Székely Mikó Kollégium restitúciós perében - közölte 2018. november 8-án Stelian Bodeanu, a bíróság szóvivője. A bírói testület ezúttal november 22-re...
2018. okt. 23.
A Gyulafehérvári Táblabíróság első fokon elutasította a gyulafehérvári egykori Gróf Majláth Gusztáv Károly Római Katolikus Gimnázium épülete visszaszolgáltatását a római katolikus egyháznak - tájékoztatta az MTI-t a táblabíróság szóvivője.  A...
2018. okt. 20.
„Állítsuk meg a szeparatistákat” felirattal és a kárpátaljai magyar közösség vezetőinek neveivel, valamint fényképeivel jelentek meg óriásplakátok szombat reggelre a főutak mellett Ungvár, Munkács és Beregszász körzetében.  A fehér alapú, ukrán...
Címkék:
2018. okt. 16.
Írásban interpellált 2018. október 16-án az ukrán parlament elnökénél és emberjogi biztosánál a törvényhozás honlapjára felkerült, a kettős állampolgárságú kárpátaljai magyarok deportálását indítványozó aláírásgyűjtő petíció blokkolását és a kettős...
2018. okt. 08.
A Bihar megyei törvényszék jogerős ítéletben elutasította a nagyváradi Szacsvay Imre Általános Iskola által használt épület visszaszolgáltatását a római katolikus egyháznak - írta 2018. október 8-i számában a Krónika című napilap. A múlt csütörtökön...
2018. okt. 03.
Ukrajna még ezen a héten kiutasítja a beregszászi magyar konzult, amennyiben Budapest nem hívja vissza őt - jelentette ki Pavlo Klimkin ukrán külügyminiszter a Facebookon közzétett videoüzenetében az UNIAN ukrán hírügynökség 2018. október 2-i...
Címkék:
2018. szep. 30.
Az ukrán büntető törvénykönyv hazaárulásra vonatkozó cikke alapján indított büntetőeljárást a Kárpátalja megyei ügyészség magyar állampolgárság kárpátaljai lakosok általi felvételének ügyében - jelentette be 2018. szeptember 28-án a megyei ügyészség...
Címkék:
2018. szep. 24.
Mintegy másfél tucat ukrán nacionalista tüntetett 2018. szeptember 24-én délelőtt Magyarország beregszászi konzulátusa előtt, követelve az összes magyar konzul kiutasítását és a konzulátus működésének beszüntetését, mert szerintük a képviselet „az...
Címkék:
2018. szep. 11.
Az ügyészség szerint nem tartalmaz uszító elemeket az a magyargyalázó falragasz, mely júniusban a Bihar megyei törvényszék falán jelent meg - tájékoztatott a Romániai Magyar Demokrata Szövetség (RMDSZ) nagyváradi szervezete, mely feljelentést tett a...
2018. szep. 07.
A román nyelv magyar elemi osztályokban történő oktatására vonatkozó kormányrendelet visszavonását vagy alkalmazásának felfüggesztését kérte 2018. szeptember 7-i nyilatkozatában a romániai Magyar Szülők Szövetsége.  A magyar szülők szervezete az MTI...
2018. aug. 21.
A Maros megyei tanfelügyelőség 2018. augusztus 20-án Tamási Zsoltot nevezte ki az újonnan megalapított marosvásárhelyi II. Rákóczi Ferenc Római Katolikus Gimnázium igazgatójává, ő töltötte be a tanintézmény tavaly felszámolt elődjének igazgatói...